Discussion about this post

User's avatar
circleglider's avatar

My wife has spent her entire career in public health law, dedicated to stopping smoking. I can assure you that the culture of her world can be completely described by one word: Puritans.

To our public health Puritans, smoking is a repulsive and vulgar habit that is only engaged in by the lower classes. Just like the Prohibitionists of the early 20th century, today’s public health community is morally at peace with killing millions of people if it helps to achieve their ultimate goal, not because they are psychopaths but because they comfortably place any blame on the victim.

The public health community’s goal is not simply to eliminate all tobacco use. They are committed to banishing all form of smoking. Forever. And to them, “smoking” is all encompassing, including vaping, whether the substance is tobacco or cannabis or any synthetic compound.

The public health community is constantly pushing to make smoking socially, culturally and politically anathema. If current smokers persist after all the public health initiatives to the contrary, any bad outcomes are the fault of the weak-willed smoker. The community expects that eventually smoking will become so socially unacceptable and legally untenable as to be indistinguishable from hard drug use.

Of course this is just another war on drugs. But the Puritan strain runs deep throughout American history. We’re going to keep killing people for their own good until everyone is dead.

Expand full comment
Warmek's avatar

> That misinformation is killing people, the CDC is doing it on purpose, and the only way to counteract it is to spread the scientific truth through unofficial channels.

Seems to be a lot of that going around, lately...

Expand full comment
80 more comments...

No posts